Technology

Danielle Thumann’s FCC nomination advances in 15-0 Senate committee vote

Senate Commerce Republicans advanced Danielle Thumann Severs after Democrats boycotted, sending her FCC nomination to the full Senate.

Hana Yoshida

By Hana Yoshida · Markets Reporter

3 min read

Danielle Thumann’s FCC nomination advances in 15-0 Senate committee vote
Photo: Ars Technica

Danielle Thumann Severs’ FCC nomination advanced from the Senate Commerce Committee on November 18 in a 15-0 vote cast only by Republicans after every Democratic member boycotted the session. The action sends President Donald Trump’s pick to the full Senate, where she would still need majority approval to join the Federal Communications Commission.

The vote matters for the makeup of the five-member agency. Reuters reported that the FCC currently has two Republicans and one Democrat, Commissioner Anna Gomez, with two seats open; three commissioners are needed for a quorum.

What happens next for Danielle Thumann’s FCC nomination?

The full Senate can now consider Thumann Severs’ nomination. Trump nominated her in August for one of the vacant seats, and she serves as senior counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr, according to Reuters and the FCC description of her role cited by Ars Technica.

Federal law bars more than three FCC commissioners from belonging to the same political party. Senate Commerce Chair Ted Cruz said the administration is not required to submit Republican and Democratic nominees together, and that the committee has previously moved FCC nominations separately, Deadline reported.

Cruz also said Thumann Severs would fill the seat left vacant by former Republican Commissioner Nathan Simington, who resigned last year, according to Deadline.

Why did Senate Democrats boycott the vote?

Committee Democrats, led by Sen. Maria Cantwell of Washington, opposed moving a Republican nominee without a paired Democratic nomination. They called for Gomez to receive another term and said the White House could renominate her quickly, Reuters and Politico reported.

Democrats said they feared confirmation of Thumann Severs could leave the FCC with enough members for a quorum if Trump later removed Gomez. That is their stated concern, not a confirmed plan by the administration.

The boycott also created a dispute over whether the committee could act without a Democrat present. Ars Technica reported that committee rules say a quorum for nomination votes includes a majority of members and at least one minority-party member. Cantwell’s office said that requirement had guided committee practice since 2005.

A Cruz spokesperson pointed instead to Senate standing-rule language requiring a majority of the committee to be physically present to report a matter, without specifying that a minority member must attend, Ars Technica reported. Cruz proceeded with the vote, with all 15 Republicans supporting the nomination and the panel’s 13 Democrats absent.

Thumann Severs has also faced Democratic scrutiny over her testimony about work involving media-related matters. Sen. Ben Ray Luján alleged that records contradicted her statement that she had not worked with Carr on such issues. In follow-up answers, Thumann Severs said she may review documents outside her designated portfolio but had no conversations with Paramount, CBS or Skydance about their merger, according to Ars Technica.

This story draws on original reporting from Ars Technica.